Rapture May 21. Bad Theology
If you haven’t figured it out by now, the rapture did not occur on May 21st 2011 as predicted by Harold Camping. There were those who took him seriously. They gave up their jobs, savings, and euthanized their pets. Camping’s ministry Family Radio put millions of dollars into a campaign to bring awareness of the rapture worldwide. There were those who didn’t believe him and most of us—myself included—spent our supposed pre-rapture days joking about it. Even the most serious media attention was covered with an undercurrent of comedic disbelief. Aside from a very good article by my friend Jeff, almost no one has actually given the event any serious attention.
The truth is that the Christians who believe in the rapture are a very loud minority. It would have been great if other believers had utilized this media attention to actually talk about what we really believe about eschatology (the study of the end times). I want to discuss eschatology and how it relates to the behavior of Christians.
I have met a lot of Christians obsessed with the end times and what bothers me most is how divisive they are about it. They are repeating history. The life, death, and resurrection of Jesus completely blindsided the Jewish community at the time. The Jewish leaders had very strong opinions about how the Messiah would come about and none of them were even close in spite of it being right in front of their faces. It was obvious and they still got it wrong. Yet we seem to think that we can get it right. So before I get too ambitious I want to take a step back and admit that there’s a good chance we’re all wrong about this whole deal. But I also think my take on eschatology leaves a lot of room for error while also centering on what is the Gospel.
As I said, eschatology is the study of end times or—literally—last things. Christians believe that the life, death, and resurrection of Jesus—God incarnate—made the way for them to be right with God. Jesus also claimed he would come again. The details are primarily outlined in Revelation, a book that is written in the form of traditional apocalyptic literature making it a little difficult for the 21st century reader. The interpretation of this and other eschatological Biblical texts is very divided. Some believe in the rapture—primarily based on a I Thessalonians 4 verse—an idea that somewhere in the future Christ will return and some or all of the believers will be lifted to Heaven to be with him.
I could spend pages discussing why this belief is categorically false. Other, better studied writers have expounded elsewhere and I think it best to leave it to them. What I’d rather talk about is why we can’t predict the Second Coming and why predicting it doesn’t matter.
The favorite passage to dispel any prophecy about the Second Coming is Mark 13:32-33: “But about that day or hour no one knows, not even the angels in heaven, nor the Son, but only the Father. Be on guard! Be alert! You do not know when that time will come.” This could be interpreted that Jesus was only speaking about his present time, that when he said this no one knew, but now in the 21st century we can know. I think that’s stretching the truth and of all the Bible passages to debate, this one seems pretty concrete. But it is the other part of this verse that interests me.
Let us say that the rapture does exist and that we can predict it. For some people who believed Camping it meant giving up money, jobs, school, work, family. For Camping it meant $100 million dollar ad campaign to raise awareness about the rapture. Yet they believed in the Second Coming before they thought they knew when it would be and here is Jesus in Mark 13 telling them to always be ready. “Be on guard! Be alert!” Given this, how does knowing the date make a difference? Shouldn’t we be living as if Jesus could come back at any moment? Yet we still take on our jobs, pets, savings, and normal lives. Are they all made meaningless if Jesus comes back? If Camping was right, shouldn’t all Christians everywhere have done like Camping’s followers all along? There’s an even bigger problem that interest me.
Most evangelicals, Camping included, would agree that to be saved one must believe that Jesus died and was resurrected for their sins. And that someone who believed that but didn’t know about the Second Coming could still saved. Yet, Camping spent his time raising awareness about the supposed rapture. What good is knowing about the rapture if you don’t know who it’s really about? I would much rather someone believe in Jesus than know the date of the rapture. The money and efforts were a waste and that’s a greater sin than getting the date wrong.
What happens in the end times and what should we do about it? As I said, there’s a lot of debate and about the only thing Christians agree on is that there will be a second coming. Some views of the end times suggest that God will destroy the world. So, what’s the point of anything? Tell everyone about Jesus and don’t worry about climate change, world hunger, having a job, or obeying Matthew 25. Other views think that Jesus is going to come back one day and just fix everything. Again, what’s the point? Some believe that since the Resurrection everything is improving all of the time. Thanks to some recent natural disasters and wars that’s a dying theology.
When do the end times start and when do things get better? Well, kind of now and kind of not yet. Here’s the conventional Gospel story: Christ died for your sins. It’s true, but it’s not the whole story. The whole story is that God created a good and perfect world. That world became imperfect when humans first sinned. This sin allowed death and decay into a world that really wasn’t meant for those things. It was meant for good. God answered this pain and suffering in the most unimaginable way possible. He became one of us and endured the same pain and suffering. He lived a perfect life and dealt with the pain and suffering in this world by enduring the worst part of it: Death. He died and three days later he returned from the dead, resurrected. Through this act, sinners who believe this story are now made right with God.
What’s different about this version? The Resurrection. It’s a very important part and it is often forgotten or ignored. But it’s important. The Resurrection means the end times are now: God’s Kingdom has come. Jesus coming back to life means that all of creation is no longer under the rule of death and decay but now given the chance of new life. It’s in the Lord’s Prayer “Thy Kingdom come on Earth as it is in Heaven.” And it is prophesied in Revelation 21 where the new heavens and earth collide and God says “See, I make all things new.”
Jesus is resurrected, which is the first glimpse of what is here and what is coming. But people still die and bad things still happen. God’s Kingdom is here and now, but not yet. How is that? Paul makes sense of this in Romans 8. He talks about how all of Creation is redeemed in Christ. It has been conceived but it’s not yet born. We are in between the pregnancy and the birth. Yes, new life is coming but we are in the labor pains. It is exciting. Scary. Thought provoking.
Religion makes people do things so that they can be saved. It is a means to an end and that end is ultimately ourselves. Christianity can be made into a religion, but the message of Christ is not religious. If you are asking “How can I not go to hell?” you are asking the wrong question. Christianity is about a gift. It’s about God giving us a redeemed life. You don’t have to believe anything about the end times or rapture. You certainly don’t have to (and can’t) be a good person. You just have to want relationship with God.
We have meaning. Our jobs, environment, life, stuff: it all matters. I’ve outlined how God is redeeming Creation. Now for what it signifies to us. Before Christ, God’s presence on earth dwelled in a very sacred part of the Jewish temple. Humans are sinners and God cannot be among sin because he is perfect. After Jesus, those who believed could now be viewed as clean by God. So, what did God do? I Corinthians 6 says that our bodies are the new temple (this happens in the events of Acts 2).
So, God is redeeming Creation and God dwells in believers. Therefore, God is redeeming Creation through believers. It’s not to say that he needs believers to redeem Creation. It is a gift to us.
The message of the Gospel is Jesus and the implication is that all things are made new. Christians are to carry this message and live out the implication. We are to make all things new. What does that look like? Love your neighbor (everyone, particularly the people you come into contact with) and love God and show it. Love your enemy. Leave things better than you found them: your relationships, your environment, your life, the lives of others. Be nice to the barista even if they don’t deserve it, pick up trash on the sidewalk, excel at your job (that you may not like), play great music, paint a picture. Read Matthew 25. It says to help the least fortunate people. Take what is broken and make it new. Create and restore.
I doubt Rage Against the Machine had Christianity in mind, but it’s quite applicable to evangelism. The mission field is wherever you go. It’s not about knocking on doors or running up to strangers and telling them about Jesus. It’s not about bombarding our friends with tracts and Bible verses. It’s about no-strings-attached relationships with people. Jesus loves you, you love Jesus, you love your friends.
Most of my friends are non-Christians. I have found that it’s almost impossible for me to have an in-depth conversation without talking about Jesus. Sometimes they get uncomfortable and I evaluate whether I’m being insensitive or if they are actually too sensitive. I want to push boundaries, but I certainly don’t want to create them. If my non-Christian friends never converted to Christianity I would still love them and treat them the same. It’s no-strings-attached friendship, yet I desperately want them to know Jesus.
The End Times aren’t about the rapture. They aren’t about Postmillennialism or Premillennialism. They are about the Gospel. The Resurrection of the Jesus means new life for everything. It means that when done right things like art, sex, nature, and life are God’s Kingdom breaking through. They are celebration of Christ and when that is realized it truly fulfills us and gives us freedom.
*For the purposes of brevity my point is ultimately watered down, however much of it is expounded on in N.T. Wright’s Surprised by Hope.
The truth is that the Christians who believe in the rapture are a very loud minority. It would have been great if other believers had utilized this media attention to actually talk about what we really believe about eschatology (the study of the end times). I want to discuss eschatology and how it relates to the behavior of Christians.
I have met a lot of Christians obsessed with the end times and what bothers me most is how divisive they are about it. They are repeating history. The life, death, and resurrection of Jesus completely blindsided the Jewish community at the time. The Jewish leaders had very strong opinions about how the Messiah would come about and none of them were even close in spite of it being right in front of their faces. It was obvious and they still got it wrong. Yet we seem to think that we can get it right. So before I get too ambitious I want to take a step back and admit that there’s a good chance we’re all wrong about this whole deal. But I also think my take on eschatology leaves a lot of room for error while also centering on what is the Gospel.
As I said, eschatology is the study of end times or—literally—last things. Christians believe that the life, death, and resurrection of Jesus—God incarnate—made the way for them to be right with God. Jesus also claimed he would come again. The details are primarily outlined in Revelation, a book that is written in the form of traditional apocalyptic literature making it a little difficult for the 21st century reader. The interpretation of this and other eschatological Biblical texts is very divided. Some believe in the rapture—primarily based on a I Thessalonians 4 verse—an idea that somewhere in the future Christ will return and some or all of the believers will be lifted to Heaven to be with him.
I could spend pages discussing why this belief is categorically false. Other, better studied writers have expounded elsewhere and I think it best to leave it to them. What I’d rather talk about is why we can’t predict the Second Coming and why predicting it doesn’t matter.
The favorite passage to dispel any prophecy about the Second Coming is Mark 13:32-33: “But about that day or hour no one knows, not even the angels in heaven, nor the Son, but only the Father. Be on guard! Be alert! You do not know when that time will come.” This could be interpreted that Jesus was only speaking about his present time, that when he said this no one knew, but now in the 21st century we can know. I think that’s stretching the truth and of all the Bible passages to debate, this one seems pretty concrete. But it is the other part of this verse that interests me.
Let us say that the rapture does exist and that we can predict it. For some people who believed Camping it meant giving up money, jobs, school, work, family. For Camping it meant $100 million dollar ad campaign to raise awareness about the rapture. Yet they believed in the Second Coming before they thought they knew when it would be and here is Jesus in Mark 13 telling them to always be ready. “Be on guard! Be alert!” Given this, how does knowing the date make a difference? Shouldn’t we be living as if Jesus could come back at any moment? Yet we still take on our jobs, pets, savings, and normal lives. Are they all made meaningless if Jesus comes back? If Camping was right, shouldn’t all Christians everywhere have done like Camping’s followers all along? There’s an even bigger problem that interest me.
Most evangelicals, Camping included, would agree that to be saved one must believe that Jesus died and was resurrected for their sins. And that someone who believed that but didn’t know about the Second Coming could still saved. Yet, Camping spent his time raising awareness about the supposed rapture. What good is knowing about the rapture if you don’t know who it’s really about? I would much rather someone believe in Jesus than know the date of the rapture. The money and efforts were a waste and that’s a greater sin than getting the date wrong.
What happens in the end times and what should we do about it? As I said, there’s a lot of debate and about the only thing Christians agree on is that there will be a second coming. Some views of the end times suggest that God will destroy the world. So, what’s the point of anything? Tell everyone about Jesus and don’t worry about climate change, world hunger, having a job, or obeying Matthew 25. Other views think that Jesus is going to come back one day and just fix everything. Again, what’s the point? Some believe that since the Resurrection everything is improving all of the time. Thanks to some recent natural disasters and wars that’s a dying theology.
When do the end times start and when do things get better? Well, kind of now and kind of not yet. Here’s the conventional Gospel story: Christ died for your sins. It’s true, but it’s not the whole story. The whole story is that God created a good and perfect world. That world became imperfect when humans first sinned. This sin allowed death and decay into a world that really wasn’t meant for those things. It was meant for good. God answered this pain and suffering in the most unimaginable way possible. He became one of us and endured the same pain and suffering. He lived a perfect life and dealt with the pain and suffering in this world by enduring the worst part of it: Death. He died and three days later he returned from the dead, resurrected. Through this act, sinners who believe this story are now made right with God.
What’s different about this version? The Resurrection. It’s a very important part and it is often forgotten or ignored. But it’s important. The Resurrection means the end times are now: God’s Kingdom has come. Jesus coming back to life means that all of creation is no longer under the rule of death and decay but now given the chance of new life. It’s in the Lord’s Prayer “Thy Kingdom come on Earth as it is in Heaven.” And it is prophesied in Revelation 21 where the new heavens and earth collide and God says “See, I make all things new.”
Jesus is resurrected, which is the first glimpse of what is here and what is coming. But people still die and bad things still happen. God’s Kingdom is here and now, but not yet. How is that? Paul makes sense of this in Romans 8. He talks about how all of Creation is redeemed in Christ. It has been conceived but it’s not yet born. We are in between the pregnancy and the birth. Yes, new life is coming but we are in the labor pains. It is exciting. Scary. Thought provoking.
Religion makes people do things so that they can be saved. It is a means to an end and that end is ultimately ourselves. Christianity can be made into a religion, but the message of Christ is not religious. If you are asking “How can I not go to hell?” you are asking the wrong question. Christianity is about a gift. It’s about God giving us a redeemed life. You don’t have to believe anything about the end times or rapture. You certainly don’t have to (and can’t) be a good person. You just have to want relationship with God.
“Love that will not betray youMumford and Sons “Sigh No More”
Dismay or enslave you
It will set you free
To be more like the man
You were made to be”
We have meaning. Our jobs, environment, life, stuff: it all matters. I’ve outlined how God is redeeming Creation. Now for what it signifies to us. Before Christ, God’s presence on earth dwelled in a very sacred part of the Jewish temple. Humans are sinners and God cannot be among sin because he is perfect. After Jesus, those who believed could now be viewed as clean by God. So, what did God do? I Corinthians 6 says that our bodies are the new temple (this happens in the events of Acts 2).
So, God is redeeming Creation and God dwells in believers. Therefore, God is redeeming Creation through believers. It’s not to say that he needs believers to redeem Creation. It is a gift to us.
The message of the Gospel is Jesus and the implication is that all things are made new. Christians are to carry this message and live out the implication. We are to make all things new. What does that look like? Love your neighbor (everyone, particularly the people you come into contact with) and love God and show it. Love your enemy. Leave things better than you found them: your relationships, your environment, your life, the lives of others. Be nice to the barista even if they don’t deserve it, pick up trash on the sidewalk, excel at your job (that you may not like), play great music, paint a picture. Read Matthew 25. It says to help the least fortunate people. Take what is broken and make it new. Create and restore.
“There’ll be no shelter hereRage Against the Machine “No Shelter”
The front lines are everywhere.”
I doubt Rage Against the Machine had Christianity in mind, but it’s quite applicable to evangelism. The mission field is wherever you go. It’s not about knocking on doors or running up to strangers and telling them about Jesus. It’s not about bombarding our friends with tracts and Bible verses. It’s about no-strings-attached relationships with people. Jesus loves you, you love Jesus, you love your friends.
Most of my friends are non-Christians. I have found that it’s almost impossible for me to have an in-depth conversation without talking about Jesus. Sometimes they get uncomfortable and I evaluate whether I’m being insensitive or if they are actually too sensitive. I want to push boundaries, but I certainly don’t want to create them. If my non-Christian friends never converted to Christianity I would still love them and treat them the same. It’s no-strings-attached friendship, yet I desperately want them to know Jesus.
The End Times aren’t about the rapture. They aren’t about Postmillennialism or Premillennialism. They are about the Gospel. The Resurrection of the Jesus means new life for everything. It means that when done right things like art, sex, nature, and life are God’s Kingdom breaking through. They are celebration of Christ and when that is realized it truly fulfills us and gives us freedom.
*For the purposes of brevity my point is ultimately watered down, however much of it is expounded on in N.T. Wright’s Surprised by Hope.
xyxytodwhy.2011
xyzrxyz.2011
Unfortunately due to the large amount of spam I receive I not only moderate all comments but also do not allow direct contact from strangers.
All comments are moderated by me so should you want to say anything personal you may comment on this blog and state that you wish to keep it private. In which case I would respect your wishes and not publish it but I alone will be able to read it and respond.